When shutting out sneaks in

Who really gets heard?
What happens under pressure?
Where do habits hide?

Here, red10 ‘s Kirsten Campbell explores one of the most revealing – and often uncomfortable – insights teams gain when they look closely at how they communicate. It’s a behaviour that frequently surprises people, can feel personal when it shows up in feedback, and yet offers one of the biggest opportunities for growth when handled well.

What framework is this from?

This is one of the 11 communicating behaviours – this one described as
RED by Professor Neil Rackham – in the Rackham Behavioural Analysis framework, which you can read in full here:

👉 https://www.red10dev.com/making-more-of-meetings

At red10 , we use the Rackham Behavioural Analysis to give individuals and teams a practical snapshot of how they are communicating in real time. The framework groups behaviours into blue, red and green, offering a clear link between how people communicate and how effective they are being.

It’s not about personality.
It’s not about intent.
It’s about observable behaviour – and choice.

What surprised me, Kirsten, the most?

When I first received my own results, I was genuinely taken aback.

I had been convinced that the more extraverted voices in the room had dominated the conversation – taking more airtime, interrupting more frequently, and shaping the discussion through sheer presence. Yet when the scores came back, it was me who sat highest in the Shutting Out box.

This moment is familiar for many people encountering the analysis for the first time. The data often challenges our internal story about how we show up in meetings – particularly when our intent doesn’t match our impact.

Why does Shutting Out feel so uncomfortable?

Of all eleven behaviours in the framework, Shutting Out tends to provoke the strongest reaction.

Because it’s classified as a red behaviour, people often interpret a high score as meaning they’ve been “bad”, “wrong” or even disrespectful. In reality, red simply means not useful in helping the group think well together.

The analysis is feedback – not judgement. What you do with that information is where the real work begins.

When are people most likely to Shutting Out?

Interestingly, people are most prone to Shutting Out behaviours when they care deeply about the subject or feel personally invested in the outcome.

When people care and yet don’t feel heard, they often try to create space for themselves – sometimes by taking it from others.

This is why Shutting Out shows up so frequently in leadership teams, strategy sessions and emotionally charged conversations. Commitment and pressure combine, and listening quietly slips down the priority list.

What does Shutting Out actually look like?

Some of the most common behaviours include:

  • Interrupting while someone else is still talking
  • Talking over another speaker
  • Side conversations happening in parallel
  • Finishing other people’s sentences for them
  • Interrupting, then waiting for “airspace” while not truly listening
  • Answering a question that was directed at someone else
  • Jumping in when someone pauses briefly to think

Seen once, these behaviours are easy to dismiss. Seen repeatedly, they shape the quality of thinking in the room.

Why is this behaviour so hard to change?

Awareness doesn’t instantly rewire habit.

Kirsten remembers vowing, after seeing her score, to say nothing at all in the next discussion – determined not to add another tick in the Shutting Out box. Unsurprisingly, it didn’t last. Passion kicked in, and silence proved neither helpful nor sustainable.

Twenty years on, this is still a behaviour she consciously works on.

The goal isn’t silence.
The goal is better listening.

Where is the real opportunity for teams?

The real shift – for individuals and teams alike – comes from deliberately building green communicating behaviours.

Green behaviours invite contribution, build on ideas, and create space for collective thinking, particularly when you are not in control or chairing the meeting.

Learning when not to speak can be just as powerful as knowing how to speak with impact.

You can ask red10

For a 2.5hr virtual Mini Skills Masterclass on Rackham Behaviours for up to 15 people

For the Two Half day Virtual or 1-day in-person Influencing Skills Masterclass that includes Rackham AND Cialdini