Who’s “hard work” is it?
What does “respect” sound like?
How do we stay curious?
Here, red10 ‘s Lisa Smith explores a familiar workplace puzzle: teams made up of people at different stages of life can sometimes feel like they’re playing the same match with different rules. Someone wants a quick Teams message; someone else prefers a phone call. One person sees flexibility as trust; another sees it as a lack of commitment. It’s easy to reach for generational labels to explain the tension.
But the evidence gives us a useful caution. Research suggests that while we often notice patterns, true generational differences are usually small, and believing they are large can shape behaviour in unhelpful ways. The Harvard Business Review article “Generational Differences at Work Are Small. Thinking They’re Big Affects Our Behavior” explains this clearly.
So rather than using labels as explanations, we can treat these moments as prompts for better conversations and clearer agreements.
What are we really noticing?
When leaders talk about generational differences, they’re often describing real experiences: different expectations about communication speed, feedback frequency, career progression, or work–life boundaries. These differences can absolutely show up in day-to-day work.
The key shift is to move from labelling people to understanding needs.
For example:
- A preference for quick messages might be about speed and efficiency.
- A desire for face-to-face conversations might reflect a need for connection and nuance.
- Requests for flexibility might signal a focus on autonomy and trust.
When we get curious about the underlying need, the conversation becomes constructive rather than comparative.
How do we stop stereotypes taking over?
Generational stories are powerful and that’s exactly why they can be risky. Once we believe “this group is like that,” we start interpreting behaviour through that lens. Over time, this can influence who gets opportunities, whose style is seen as professional, and how performance is judged.
A helpful leadership move is to make it explicit: we don’t manage people by category; we manage through agreements.
Below are examples of different ways of working that teams can explicitly choose between.
Communication channel
- Quick updates → Teams/Slack message
- Complex topics → Phone or video call
- Sensitive conversations → Face-to-face
Response expectations
- Urgent → within 1–2 hours
- Same day → by close of play
- Non-urgent → within 24–48 hours
Meetings
- Decision needed → live meeting
- Information share → written update
- Brainstorming → workshop format
Feedback
- In-the-moment coaching
- Scheduled monthly check-ins
- Written reflections
Flexibility
- Fixed core hours + flexible start/finish
- Outcome-based deadlines
- Hybrid location choice
By making options explicit, teams replace assumption with agreement.
What does flexibility really mean?
Flexibility works best when it sits alongside clarity. Without clear expectations, flexibility can feel like inconsistency; without flexibility, clarity can feel rigid.
A practical way to balance this is to separate work into three buckets:
- Fixed: the non-negotiables (client commitments, safety, key deadlines).
- Flexible: the areas where people can choose how they work best (location, learning style, planning approach).
- Flag early: the shared rule that keeps trust intact — if something might slip, say so early.
This approach removes much of the tension that can otherwise be attributed to “different generations”.
How do we build a culture that works for everyone?
The most effective teams don’t aim to eliminate differences; they aim to make them visible and workable.
One simple intervention is a short “preferences conversation.” Ask each team member:
- What’s the best way to reach you quickly?
- What should we know about how you work under pressure?
- What kind of feedback helps you improve most?
Capture the answers and turn them into a lightweight team guide. The act of sharing often matters more than the document itself; it signals respect and reduces guesswork.
A Research-based communication tool
Regardless of generational preferences, there is one constant: the quality of conversations shapes the quality of outcomes. This is where Rackham’s evidence-based communication behaviours provide a practical anchor. Unlike personality labels or generational assumptions, these behaviours are observable, learnable, and measurable — which means teams can build skill rather than rely on guesswork.
Behaviours such as testing understanding, building on others’ ideas, and clearly summarising agreements help conversations land well regardless of age, role, or style. They create a shared language for what “good communication” looks like, making it easier to challenge constructively, listen actively, and keep discussions outcome-focused.
For leaders, this shifts the focus from who people are to what they do in conversations. And that’s powerful, because behaviour is something we can practise and improve together.
You can explore these behaviours and how to apply them in everyday meetings here:
So what’s the leadership takeaway?
Differences in how people approach work are real — but they rarely fit neatly into generational boxes. The most useful stance for leaders is curiosity over certainty.
Instead of asking, “Which generation is right?” ask:
- What outcome are we all trying to achieve?
- What does each person need to do their best work?
- What agreements will help us deliver consistently?
When teams focus on clarity, flexibility, and open conversation, the narrative shifts. What once felt like generational tension becomes a source of insight — a broader range of perspectives, experiences, and ways of solving problems.
And that’s the real opportunity. Not to manage generations, but to lead humans well — creating environments where differences are understood, expectations are clear, and everyone can contribute at their best.