Mediating between groups
Is your group in conflict with another group?
Are you wondering if mediation might help?
Would you like to know how group:group mediation works?
As a qualified mediator, here, red10 ‘s Will Sudworth explains the process…
Mediating between groups
Mediation can help to resolve conflict between:
- Individuals, e.g. two members of staff, or a line manager and their direct report
- Groups, e.g. two departments in the same company
- Companies, e.g. two companies working together on developing a drug.
So, you’re going to sort this conflict out for me, right?
No.
The first thing to be aware of is that the mediator doesn’t sort anything out. You do.
Mediators create safe spaces for people in conflict to work out the issues between themselves. This is what makes mediation so special.
Amongst other things, mediation requires:
- Both groups to take part voluntarily, and to want it to work
- Both groups to keep the contents of the mediation in strictest confidence, so that they protect each other’s reputation. This is a bit like Vegas Rules, i.e. “what happens in Vegas stays in Vegas”
- Both groups to agree that there will be a minimum of three gatherings:
Click here for the full set of requirements.
How does mediation work?
Step 1: Each group meets separately with the mediator
The leader(s) of both groups, meet separately with the mediator.
Sometimes this results in their entire group meeting with the mediator.
The mediator will form an agreement with the leaders from each group, that:
- This separate meeting is in strictest confidence, i.e. unless your group says it to the other party, then it won’t be said
- The mediator will treat both groups equally
The mediator helps the leader(s) of each group to:
- Order their thoughts – by allowing the opportunity to offload to an empathetic and attentive listener.
- Discover how to state your positive intent so that you can share it with the other group
- Discover what you would like to be different, and turn this vision into requests about the future, phrased as “I would like it if…”
This is useful, because often people are unclear, even in their own minds, about the outcomes they would like to achieve.
In fact, when people are in conflict they tend to:
rather than
With group mediation, we sometimes invite a representative sample of both groups to have 30-min calls so that we can create a carefully written Feedback-on-a-Page that helps both groups understand each other better before even getting in the room.
Step 2: The first gathering ground rules
Next, we bring both groups together for a constructive and respectful meeting.
We begin by proposing ground rules – and agreeing them having refined the set through asking for additions or changes. We’ve found a helpful set of ground rules to be:
- Aim for a win:win
- Be curious about what needs the other group has, that has led to them taking the position they’ve taken, to help you find common ground and a win:win
- Use clean language – we don’t mean avoid swearing, we mean avoid judgemental and inflammatory words and stick to facts
- State positive intent
- State what you DO want, and state it as a request
- Don’t explore the past; instead make requests for the now-future that learn from the past
- An individual and/or a group can ask to meet separately with the Mediator at any time – including the Mediator. A short pause and a cup of tea can work wonders to keep things moving forwards positively.
- We will use Fist-5 to speed-up forming agreements
Step 3: The First Gathering – Listening to and clustering well-intended requests
The late Stephen Covey encouraged us, in his 7-habits of highly effective people, to assume positive intent.
In our mediations, we encourage you to not just assume it, but to STATE it, and to then follow that statement with a request for the future.
There is something very positive, constructive and disarming in a well-intended request that increases the chances of a positive response.
It’s really important that both groups listen to each other. It is all too easy for each party to interrupt to correct each other or respond to just one part of the request and perhaps not hear the full context or the most important words. To aid both groups, the mediator will insist on “no interruptions other than from the mediator testing their understanding and taking notes”.
In group mediation we often facilitate this way:
- Two sticky notes each
- Each sticky note states your positive intent, followed by a request
- We will take it in turns to share one sticky, and then invite you to ask “Does anyone else have something the same or similar to my request?”. We ask you to facilitate the clustering of requests. We invite you to circle and label the request cluster. The co-creating of clusters encourages the groups that they can work together and form agreements.
We usually find that:
- A small number of clusters are requests only from one group – this is important data, in itself, and these are not to be dismissed just because they only come from one group
- The majority of clusters are requests from both groups, such that the stickies allow you to see the same issue through both sets of eyes. It is helpful to see that both groups want the same thing…
We usually then ask the groups to prioritise the clusters, either through:
- Sticky dot voting
or - The leader(s) proposing a priority order for the groups to give their Fist-5 opinion on
or - The Mediator proposing a sequence to tackling the clusters
Step 4: The First Gathering – Responding to requests
It’s helpful to have a break, before responding to the requests.
There are options for the groups at this point:
- It might even be helpful for both groups to meet separately to discuss the prioritising request clusters before the groups come back together.
- You might want to tackle the priority cluster together, with the Mediator facilitating
or
- It might be possible to use breakout groups – with a representative mix from both groups – to turn the requests into a proposal for the whole to hear, refine and agree to
Either way, the aim is to turn the requests into:
Alliance Actions – with “Who-When-What” agreed
and
Partnership Principles. Principles tend to be things like behaviours, ways of working or meeting patterns. Again, these can then be agreed.
What happens after Gathering #1?
Knowing that you will meet again – at a Gathering #2 – to celebrate success and resolve gaps…we encourage you to trust each other to do the best you can, with the resources you have available, to hold to the actions and principles you agreed. We find that the Probability of Success (PoS) is increased if there is a project manager or Chief of Staff – or a pair of these – that are given authority to track progress.
At Gathering #3, both groups have normally found a good new rhythm of working with each other, and can then form a pattern that no longer needs the involvement of the Mediator.
What’s the success rate?
The Probability of Success (PoS) is high if:
- Both groups have a genuine desire to improve your relationship
- The solution to the problem is within the control/influence of both groups
- Both groups are willing to accept that they will need to make some changes
We can’t promise success. And there are times when we will refuse to mediate as the conditions are not in place to make it a good use of everyone’s time.
Yet we can promise you that we’ll do everything we can to help you have a positive, future-focused and adult conversation.
Could mediation help your group form a better working relationship with another group?