Trouble getting agreement?
Or losing time violently agreeing yet still discussing it over and over?
Or making agreements yet you know a few haven’t spoken-up?
Here, Gavin Simpson introduces the red10 way of using Fist-5 for Speed
Why are we having this conversation again? We’d sorted this…
Whilst some of the team agreed, it was obvious that the majority didn’t. You could sense the frustration in the room.
It was the perfect time to equip the team with one of red10’s favourite tools for increasing clarity with speed: Fist-5.
Have you been in a meeting where everyone is violently agreeing and yet we’re still discussing it over and over?
Or the opposite, have you been in a meeting whereby a vocal person thinks their proposal is getting a lot of support because no-one is objecting, but you know that there are at least two people who aren’t bought in to the idea?
Fist-5 is a very simple tool that allows teams to find out everyone’s current opinion quickly, allowing the conversation to then focus where it needs to.
It’s a tool that helps you get spread of opinion – it helps decision-making, yet it is NOT a tool for decision-making: we’ll explain why later in this article
How does the tool work?
Fist-5 is simply a way of asking people to give a score – from 0 (holding up a fist) through to 5 (holding up the thumb and all fingers).A great way of using it is to say:
My proposal is X, let’s Fist-5 to quickly see what people think. 1-2-3…
Or
How supportive would you be on a Fist-5? 1-2-3…
The scores have meaning:

I fully agree. Let’s move on

I agree yet there is something you need to know. I won’t take the precious air-time by explaining it now…I will share it with you outside the meeting.

I disagree yet I only have one condition*. The whole team need to hear it, as it might change the proposal for them.

I disagree and have a few conditions.*

I disagree and have quite a lot of issues that may change your mind.

I disagree, and I have a counter proposal
*typical examples of conditions we experience:
- “I don’t understand how the proposal helps deliver on aspect X of the challenge”.
- “It needs to have more detail before I can agree”
- “It needs to have a timeline for me to agree”
- “I still don’t feel as though we are clear on what we are trying to solve for”,
- “I don’t feel this is an innovative enough approach that will accelerate our timelines”.
What happens next is important…
A result of mainly 3s and 4s but with one 5 and one 0 could be followed by “Let’s listen to the 5 and the 0 talk to each other and see where that gets us to”.
Do you have several low scores? Then we’ve found it works best if you listen to each of the low scores – uninterrupted other than questions for clarity – before responding…as responding to just the first one can take you down a rabbit hole.
The key is: be curious yet disciplined.
Where are you trying to land a Fist-5?
The result your after is normally one of these outcomes:
- The original proposal gets alignment and commitment
- A refined version of the proposal gets agreement
- A counter proposal gets agreement
- The decision-maker is able to genuinely say: “I heard the views, including the disagreement, and I will take the risk: we will do this. Thank you for speaking up. I now need you to disagree yet commit.”
This fourth outcome is the reason we say that Fist-5 helps decision-making yet isn’t a decision-making tool…if you only used Fist-5 without the healthy discussion then you can fall into the trap of consensus decisions.
Fist-5 for Speed
Using Fist-5 really speeds up teams and increases clarity and buy-in.
When I first read about Fist-5, I thought it would never work. I thought that people would find it too awkward to use in practice.
But now I find the opposite. In teams in which I myself am a member, I am surprised to find myself raising my hand to give my score on the suggestion even when the rest of the team don’t yet know how Fist-5 works.
You can use this in virtual meetings too – including those without video – by simply entering your score in the chat room window.
My proposal is that every team starts using Fist-5 this year, either by themselves or having been helped to do so by a red10 team effectiveness coach – let’s Fist-5 quickly now to see what everyone thinks…