Why aren’t your top performers jumping at the chance to use AI?
What’s really holding them back?
How can you help them get on board?
Will Sudworth, with a little help from AI, takes a closer look at why your star team members might be hesitant about new tech and what you can do to shift the mindset.
So what’s the hold-up with AI?
AI is changing the way we work and fast. But here’s something surprising from a 2024 study by Ilanit SimanTov-Nachlieli in Organization Science: the people you’d expect to be first in line to use AI, your top performers, are often the ones holding back.
Why?
After running five big experiments, the researchers found that when people are told they’re high achievers, they’re actually less likely to want AI tools. It’s not just about confidence, it’s about status. They worry that AI might level the playing field and take away what makes them stand out.
What’s really going on?
Imagine you’re known as the go-to person on your team. You’ve spent years building your skills, earning trust, and proving your worth. Then along comes AI, promising to boost everyone’s performance.
Suddenly, it feels like your edge might disappear.
The study found that top performers feared AI would help others “catch up,” making their own hard-earned advantage less special. One participant summed it up perfectly:
“It’s frustrating—I worked to get where I am. If everyone else improves overnight, what was all that effort for?”
It’s not that they hate tech, it’s that they’re trying to protect what makes them unique. Even in made-up scenarios, high performers were less excited about AI, rated it lower, and questioned its benefits all because of status worries.
How can leaders help?
When introducing new tech, managers usually talk about how it saves time or cuts down mistakes. But for your top performers, that’s not enough. They need a different kind of conversation.
Here’s what can help:
Moving forward together
Teams that thrive won’t just adopt AI, they’ll help each person see it as a way to grow, not shrink. The real win comes from being the first to adapt, evolve, and lead.
So, what’s one conversation you could start this week about what people feel they might lose—and how they can find new ways to feel proud of their progress?